line decor
  
line decor


Towards a Framework of Investigating Leadership Praxis in Intercultural Contexts         
COLLARD John

Leadership beliefs and praxis are shaped by values from national, institutional and system cultures. However the dominant educational leadership discourses have frequently assumed a mono-cultural reality and their appropriateness when working with indigenous, multi-cultural and international contexts is limited. In the past decade scholars have begun arguing for a more “culturally sensitive approach” (Trompenaars, 1993, 1997; Begley, 2000; Chapman, 2000; Hallinger & Kantamara, 2000; Ribbins & Gronn, 2000; Walker & Dimmock, 2002) and cautioned about unmediated “cultural borrowing” (Leithwood & Duke, 1998; Walker & Dimmock, 2000). Early research efforts to counter this have employed cross-cultural theory to map differences between national cultures and identified values such as power distance, individualsim/collectivism, masculinity/femininity, uncertainty avoidance, long/short term orientations as important variables (Hofstede 1980, 1986, 1995: Cheng; Walker & Dimmock, 2000;  Walker, 2003). Whilst this has been an important development, the epistemological foundations and research methods of this approach cannot help explain interactions between agents from different cultures.  The cross-cultural approach relies upon static and stereotyped generalizations about national cultures and fails to accommodate that such cultures are themselves a mix of complex elements which are changing and evolving (Beck, 1993). It also ignores the reality of important indigenous, ethnic, institutional or generational sub-cultures within nation states. Nor can it provide us with fine-grained analysis of what actually happens when leaders from different cultural frameworks interact. More finely focused and phenomenological approaches are needed to render this knowledge. We need fine-tuned case studies utilizing phenomenological methods to identify the reactions and cognitive changes occurring in particular individuals from different cultural frameworks in specific contexts. A growing body of such research approaches in other aspects of education ( Kvale, 1996; Marton, 1996; Marton & Pang, 1999; Collard, 2000, 2002) may help us move towards a second generation of studies in leadership praxis in a culturally diverse world.

  ABSTRACTS FULL PAPERS
 

Copyright: CCEAM and authors, October 2006
Designed by Top Kinisis Travel Public Ltd